New Nordic Cuisine in Iceland: The Restaurant Revolution

Iceland's culinary landscape has undergone a seismic transformation over the past two decades. What was once dismissed as a nation subsisting on fermented shark and dried fish has emerged as one of Europe's most dynamic gastronomic destinations, pioneering a distinctly Icelandic interpretation of New Nordic cuisine that has captured international attention and Michelin recognition.

The Genesis of Iceland's Culinary Renaissance

The roots of Iceland's restaurant revolution trace back to the early 2000s, when a generation of Icelandic chefs began returning from prestigious kitchens in Copenhagen, London, and New York. Armed with refined techniques and a newfound appreciation for their homeland's pristine ingredients, these culinary pioneers began reimagining traditional Icelandic fare through a contemporary lens.

The movement gained momentum following the 2008 financial crisis, which paradoxically liberated Icelandic restaurateurs from the constraints of imported luxury ingredients. Forced to look inward, chefs discovered an extraordinary pantry in their own backyard: wild herbs like angelica and crowberries, pristine seafood from the North Atlantic, and lamb that grazed on nutrient-rich highland pastures.

Dill: Iceland's First Michelin Star

The watershed moment arrived in 2017 when Dill, located on Laugavegur 59 in central Reykjavík, became Iceland's first restaurant to receive a Michelin star. Chef Gunnar Karl Gíslason's seven-course tasting menu (18,500 ISK/€120) exemplifies the New Nordic philosophy: hyper-local sourcing, seasonal variation, and innovative preparation techniques that honour rather than mask natural flavours.

Dill's success opened floodgates. The restaurant operates with just 30 seats and requires reservations weeks in advance, particularly during summer months. The menu changes entirely with Iceland's dramatic seasons, featuring foraged mushrooms and berries in autumn, preserved and fermented ingredients through winter, and fresh herbs and vegetables during the brief but intense summer growing season.

The Michelin Wave Continues

Following Dill's breakthrough, Iceland's fine dining scene has continued its upward trajectory. Óx, helmed by Thráinn Freyr Vigfússon, earned its Michelin star in 2019 for its innovative approach to Icelandic ingredients. Located at Tryggvagata 8, Óx offers a theatrical dining experience where each of the 11 courses (22,000 ISK/€143) tells a story of Iceland's landscape and culture.

More recently, Moss at Laugavegur 107 joined the Michelin ranks, with chef Andri Ólafsson creating what critics describe as "edible landscapes" that mirror Iceland's dramatic terrain. The restaurant's 16-course journey (24,000 ISK/€156) incorporates elements like volcanic salt, glacier ice, and herbs foraged from specific regions across the island.

Beyond Fine Dining: The Broader Movement

The New Nordic revolution extends far beyond Michelin-starred establishments. Reykjavík's Grandi district has become a particular hotbed of innovation. Matur og Drykkur, occupying the former Saga Museum building, offers refined interpretations of traditional Icelandic dishes. Their fermented shark croquettes and langoustine with wild thyme (mains 3,800-5,200 ISK/€25-34) demonstrate how historical preservation techniques can create contemporary flavours.

Messinn, with locations on Lækjargata and Grandagarður, has revolutionised Iceland's fish cookery traditions. Their signature pan-fried fish served directly in cast iron pans (2,890-3,990 ISK/€19-26) showcases the quality of Icelandic cod, haddock, and Arctic char without unnecessary embellishment.

The Foraging Culture

Central to Iceland's New Nordic movement is an intensified focus on foraging. Professional foragers now supply restaurants with wild angelica, sea buckthorn, and dulse seaweed harvested from specific coastal areas. Crowberries from the Westfjords, wild mushrooms from birch forests near Lake Mývatn, and herbs from the Westman Islands have become signature ingredients distinguishing Icelandic cuisine from its Nordic neighbours.

Restaurants like Kol, situated at Skólavörðustígur 40, have built entire menu sections around foraged ingredients. Their tasting menu (12,500 ISK/€81) features courses entirely composed of plants and fungi found within 50km of Reykjavík, challenging perceptions of Iceland as a barren landscape.

The Farm-to-Table Movement

Iceland's volcanic soil and geothermal energy have enabled a remarkable expansion in local agriculture. Geothermally heated greenhouses now produce tomatoes, cucumbers, and herbs year-round, while highland farms raise cattle and sheep on pesticide-free pastures.

Friðheimar, located 64km southeast of Reykjavík near the Golden Circle route, exemplifies this agricultural renaissance. Their greenhouse restaurant serves tomato-based dishes using fruit grown on-site, powered entirely by geothermal energy. The facility produces 370 tonnes of tomatoes annually, supplying restaurants across Reykjavík.

Practical Considerations for Culinary Travellers

Reservations at top-tier establishments require advance booking, particularly from June through August. Dill, Óx, and Moss typically open reservations 60 days in advance, with prime weekend slots filling within hours.

Budget-conscious travellers can experience New Nordic principles at more accessible venues. Hlölla Bátar at the harbour serves exceptional fish soup (1,890 ISK/€12), while Brauð & Co's sourdough bread incorporates ancient Icelandic grains.

Most fine dining establishments offer wine pairings, though Iceland's punitive alcohol duties mean a bottle of wine costs 8,000-15,000 ISK (€52-97). Many restaurants now feature Icelandic craft beers and innovative non-alcoholic pairings using local herbs and berries.

The Future of Icelandic Cuisine

Iceland's culinary revolution shows no signs of slowing. Young chefs continue pushing boundaries, experimenting with fermentation techniques, wild game preparations, and even insects as sustainable protein sources. The opening of several cooking schools in Reykjavík suggests this movement will continue evolving, cementing Iceland's position as an essential destination for serious food lovers.

The transformation from culinary backwater to gastronomic destination represents more than mere trendiness—it reflects Iceland's broader cultural confidence and creative renaissance, making the island's restaurants as compelling a reason to visit as its glaciers and geysers.

Getting around Iceland is easiest by car. Compare rental options and find the best deals on Discover Cars — free cancellation available.

Planning your Iceland trip? Don't forget travel insurance — SafetyWing offers flexible Nomad Insurance from $56.28/4 weeks, ideal for Iceland's dramatic terrain and ever-changing conditions. Get covered before you go and explore with confidence.