Budget Eating in Reykjavik: Eating Well for Less

Reykjavik's reputation as an expensive dining destination is well-earned, with restaurant meals often costing 4,000-8,000 ISK (€25-50) per person. However, Iceland's capital offers numerous ways to experience excellent local cuisine without emptying your wallet. From street food pioneers to traditional bakeries and clever shopping strategies, eating well on a budget in Reykjavik requires insider knowledge rather than compromise on quality.

Understanding Reykjavik's Food Landscape

The key to budget dining in Reykjavik lies in understanding where locals eat versus where tourists congregate. Laugavegur and the Old Town harbour excellent restaurants, but prices reflect their prime locations. Meanwhile, areas like Grandi, Vesturbær, and along Sæbraut offer authentic experiences at significantly lower costs.

Food trucks and casual eateries have revolutionised Reykjavik's dining scene since 2010, driven partly by young chefs seeking affordable ways to showcase their skills. This movement has created a parallel food culture where 1,500-2,500 ISK (€9-15) delivers restaurant-quality meals.

Street Food and Food Trucks

Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur

Iceland's most famous hot dog stand, operating since 1937, remains unbeatable value at 350 ISK (€2.20) per pylsa. Located at Tryggvagata 1, near the harbour, this tiny stand serves 300-400 hot dogs daily using locally-sourced lamb, pork, and beef. Order yours "eina með öllu" (one with everything) for the full experience of crispy onions, raw onions, ketchup, mustard, and remoulade.

Hlölla Bátar

This food truck at Grandi Mathöll has elevated Icelandic street food since 2017. Their signature dish—slow-cooked lamb in traditional bread with pickled vegetables—costs 1,890 ISK (€12) and easily satisfies two light appetites. The truck operates Tuesday-Sunday, 11:30-21:00.

Marshall Restaurant

Technically a restaurant but priced like street food, Marshall at Grandagarður 2 specialises in gourmet burgers for 1,590-2,190 ISK (€10-14). Their beef comes from Kjöt & fiskur, Iceland's premium meat supplier, making this exceptional value for the quality delivered.

Bakeries and Cafés

Brauð & Co

This local chain operates five locations across Reykjavik, with the original at Frakkastígur 16 serving as a neighbourhood institution since 2016. Their cinnamon buns (kanilsnúður) cost 390 ISK (€2.50) and consistently rank among Europe's finest pastries. The sourdough bread, made with Icelandic flour and traditional techniques, costs 590 ISK (€3.70) per loaf.

Sandholt Bakery

Founded in 1920, Sandholt at Laugavegur 36 represents four generations of baking expertise. While prices reflect the prime location, their lunch sandwiches (1,200-1,800 ISK/€7.50-11) use exceptional ingredients including house-cured salmon and artisanal cheeses. The chocolate croissants, available from 08:00 daily, rival anything found in Paris.

Deig Workshop

This artisanal bakery at Hafnarstræti 18 focuses on naturally leavened breads and seasonal pastries. Their Friday pizza nights offer authentic Neapolitan pizzas for 2,200-2,800 ISK (€14-18)—excellent value considering the quality of imported Italian ingredients.

Smart Grocery Shopping

Bónus Supermarkets

Recognised by their bright yellow pig logo, Bónus offers Iceland's lowest grocery prices. The downtown location at Laugavegur 59 stocks everything needed for self-catering. Skyr costs 180-220 ISK (€1.15-1.40), while fresh fish from Icelandic waters runs 1,200-2,000 ISK per kilogram (€7.50-12.50).

Nóatún Fish Market

Located at Vesturgata 2a, this wholesale fish market sells directly to consumers Tuesday-Friday, 10:00-17:00. Fresh Atlantic cod costs 800 ISK per kilogram (€5), roughly half the supermarket price. The quality matches Reykjavik's finest restaurants.

10-11 Convenience Stores

While typically expensive, 10-11 stores offer excellent prepared foods. Their fish soup (fiskisúpa), available at most locations for 650 ISK (€4), uses traditional recipes and fresh ingredients. The lamb sandwich costs 890 ISK (€5.60) and provides substantial portions.

Happy Hours and Lunch Specials

Many restaurants offer lunch menus at 40-50% below dinner prices. Apotek Restaurant's lunch features three courses for 3,900 ISK (€24.50) compared to their dinner tasting menu at 12,900 ISK (€81). Similarly, Dill Restaurant offers a lunch menu for 5,900 ISK (€37) versus their evening experience at 16,900 ISK (€106).

Happy hour extends beyond alcohol to include food specials. Between 15:00-18:00, many establishments offer small plates and appetisers at reduced prices, perfect for exploring multiple venues.

Seasonal Considerations

Budget dining varies significantly by season. Summer brings food trucks and outdoor markets, while winter sees more indoor comfort food options. The Reykjavik Flea Market (Kolaportið), open weekends year-round, offers traditional foods like fermented shark and dried fish at authentic prices.

Restaurant Week occurs twice yearly (February and August), when premium establishments offer fixed-price menus representing exceptional value. Reservations fill quickly, particularly for Michelin-recommended restaurants participating in the programme.

Final Strategies

Successful budget dining in Reykjavik combines advance planning with spontaneous discoveries. Download the Reykjavik City Card app for restaurant discounts, but don't overlook unmarked food trucks and neighbourhood cafés where locals queue for lunch. The best meals often cost less than expected—you simply need to know where to look.

Getting around Iceland is easiest by car. Compare rental options and find the best deals on Discover Cars — free cancellation available.

Browse and book tours and activities on GetYourGuide — glacier hikes, whale watching, northern lights tours, Golden Circle day trips and hundreds more. Instant confirmation, free cancellation on most bookings.

Planning your Iceland trip? Don't forget travel insurance — SafetyWing offers flexible Nomad Insurance from $56.28/4 weeks, ideal for Iceland's dramatic terrain and ever-changing conditions. Get covered before you go and explore with confidence.